← Back to Blog

Finding Deals on Vintage Video Games and Consoles

Vintage video games and consoles are one of the best categories for deal hunters right now. Values have climbed steadily over the past decade, sellers frequently underestimate what they have, and local pickup listings often sit untouched because casual buyers assume games are worthless. That assumption is your edge.

Why Games and Consoles Get Underpriced

Most sellers inherited a box of games from a sibling, found them in a storage unit, or are cleaning out a kid's old room. They don't recognize the difference between a common sports title worth a dollar and a late-run RPG or platformer worth $80. A box labeled “misc old Nintendo stuff — $30 takes all” can easily contain $200 worth of games once you know what to look for.

Condition labels also get misapplied. Sellers use “works great” even on consoles they haven't tested, and “some scratches” on a game that's actually near-mint. That vagueness keeps other buyers away — but you can ask the right questions before showing up.

What to Search For

Cast a wide net with your initial searches, then narrow by platform. Useful search terms:

• Platform names: Nintendo 64, Super Nintendo, SNES, Sega Genesis, Game Boy, PlayStation 1, Dreamcast, Atari
• Bundled listings: “game lot,” “box of games,” “video game collection,” “retro games”
• High-value titles: Search for specific games you know hold value — Chrono Trigger, EarthBound, Panzer Dragoon Saga, Conker's Bad Fur Day, Little Samson
• Accessories: “Nintendo controller,” “light gun,” “game cartridges” — accessories are often thrown in free or priced low

Misspellings are especially common with older titles and console names. Sellers write “Sega Genisis,” “Super Nintindo,” “Atrai,” or mangle specific game titles entirely. Those listings get almost no traffic. For a deeper look at this angle, see how misspellings on eBay lead to serious deals.

Platforms Worth Prioritizing

Not all retro hardware is equal. Some platforms have more underpriced listings than others right now:

1. Nintendo 64 — Chunky cartridges look toy-like, but complete-in-box N64 games regularly sell for $40–$150+. Sellers routinely price them at $5–$10.
2. Sega Saturn and Dreamcast — Less mainstream, so sellers assume low value. Saturn's library is especially undervalued locally.
3. Original PlayStation — Black-disc RPGs and JRPGs (Final Fantasy, Xenogears, Suikoden II) can run $50–$300+ complete. They look indistinguishable from worthless sports games to untrained eyes.
4. Handheld systems — Game Boy, Game Boy Advance, and DS lots often get lumped together cheaply. GBA carts in particular punch above their apparent value.

Craigslist vs. eBay Strategy

On Craigslist, focus on “lots” and bundled listings — this is where you find the $30 box that pays for itself three times over. Move fast; good lots disappear within hours. Local pickup also lets you inspect before buying, which matters for console condition.

On eBay, filter by recently listed Buy It Now prices and sort by lowest price + shipping. Look for sellers who clearly don't know values — short descriptions, bad photos, no mention of specific titles. Auctions with no bids in the final hour are also worth watching. For broader Craigslist tactics, the Craigslist deal hunting guide covers fundamentals that apply here too.

Quick Valuation Checks

Before you commit, run a fast price check:

• PriceCharting.com — The standard reference for retro game values. Shows loose, complete, and new-in-box prices.
• eBay sold listings — Filter by “Sold Items” to see what actually cleared, not just what sellers are asking.

Even a 60-second phone check at a garage sale or before messaging a seller can tell you whether to move fast or walk away.

Set Alerts So You Don't Miss a Drop

The best local game lots get scooped within an hour of posting. The only way to consistently beat other buyers is to see listings the moment they go up. LurkMor lets you set free email alerts for Craigslist and eBay searches — so when someone lists a “box of N64 games” in your area, you know about it right away. Set up searches for your target platforms and check the alert as soon as it hits your inbox.